A few years back, a friend gave an interesting view on reading. She claims that the first book you read by an author is nearly always the one you like best. I’m not necessarily talking about the author’s first book—rather, the book by that author that you read first.
When my friend said it, I thought, yes, that’s exactly right. Now, I’m not so sure. I think back over some of the authors I’ve “discovered,†and in some cases I liked the first book I read the best, but in others, I liked later books as much or more.I’m going to talk about some of those books here.
Please note, just because I say I like one book best, it doesn’t mean I didn’t like, or even love, the author’s other books. I’m just talking about that book I would name as my favorite by that author.
The “first is best†rule holds true for me with some authors. Anita Shreve’s Fortune’s Rocks was the first I read of hers and is still my favorite. My Sister’s Keeper is my first and best read from Jodi Picoult. Prince of Lies (Harlequin Presents) is my first and favorite book by Robyn Donald. The Heiress Takes a Husband is, I think, my favorite book by Silhouette author Cara Colter, and it was also the first I read (it was part of trilogy, BTW, and somehow I missed the other two books, which is a lasting regret!).
But on the other hand… Lucy Sullivan is Getting Married was the first book I read by Marian Keyes, but Rachel’s Holiday is so far my favorite. This Heart of Mine was my first Susan Elizabeth Phillips book, but although it’s still right up there, I think I prefer Kiss an Angel or Match Me If You Can. Marrying Marcus is my favorite book from Silhouette author Laurey Bright, who also writes as Daphne Clair, but it was by no means the first I read. With Sophie Kinsella’s Shopaholic series, I think I’ve enjoyed all the books equally.
I rather enjoy sitting around remembering books I’ve read and debating (with myself, mostly) which is the best. How about you? Do you think the first book you read by an author tends to be the best, or does that have nothing to do with it?
Abby
Books on sale or free
Featured Books
ONCE UPON A TIME: Sweet, Funny, and Strange Tales for All Ages
Step through our castle doors into a world of imagination!
More info →
QUEEN OF THE UNIVERSE
Can a charismatic TV writer convince her brooding handyman to star in her show in time to save her career?
More info →
Hi Kitty, it’s always interesting to hear other people’s favorites too! I’ll check out the Garwood adn Devereaux books. The first Jennifer Crusie book I read was Fast Women, but my favorite was Bet Me or Man-Hunting.
Abby
What a fun question, Abby! Looking over my stack of Books I’m Never Getting Rid Of, I’d say the first book only helps me decide if I’m going to read more. The Gift by Julie Garwood, and Knight in Shining Armor by Jude Devereaux are my favorites by those authors, but not (by far!) the first of theirs I read. Nobody’s Baby But Mine by Susan Elizabeth Philips, and Faking It by Jennifer Crusie, were the first books I read by those authors because they were the faves of friends who suggested them. I love them both, but now I’ve read EVERYTHING by both authors and like some of their other books even better. 🙂